Hand-Crafted Pizza

Made To Order

OUR MISSION

At Martha’s Pizza, we aim to please your palate with each pizza we craft!

Our hand-crafted pizzas begin with dough made fresh daily from Nantucket Baking Company. Hand-tossing the dough adds tradition; our house-made sauce and fresh ingredients add authenticity and freshness.

OUR PIZZAS

Our 12-inch hand-made gourmet pizzas are created using the finest ingredients with your choice of house-made sauces and our unique mozzarella cheese blend. Every pizza is baked with your choice of a crispy Neapolitan or gluten-free crust (add $3.00).

  • Cheese pizza with tomato sauce, shredded cheese, and additional tomato sauce and shredded cheese on the side.

    THE ORIGINAL

    $9.99

    A classic cheese pizza on our crispy Neapolitan-style crust. Create your own masterpiece using this personal selection of ingredients from our extensive list of toppings and seasonings.

  • A freshly baked pizza with green bell peppers, red onions, black olives, and possibly chicken on a wooden table, surrounded by bowls of tomato sauce, cheese, pepperoni, and mushrooms, along with some scissors and a green drink.

    EXTRA SPECIAL

    $14.99

    Six toppings make this one a classic: pepperoni, fresh Italian sausage, onions, fresh mushrooms, Kalamata olives, and green peppers.

  • A mushroom and onion pizza with green sauce on the side, grilled meat on a white plate, and fresh mushrooms and shredded cheese on a wooden table.

    CHICKEN PESTO

    $14.99

    A pie with punch: flavor-packed basil pesto, red onions, fresh mushrooms, and grilled chicken.

  • Fresh pineapple, slices of pepperoni, green jalapeños, ham, steak slices, shredded cheese, and tomato sauce surrounding a cooked pizza with toppings on a wooden table.

    THE VOLCANO

    $14.99

    A Hawaiian slice with a kick! This three-meat pizza of pepperoni, ham, and bacon brings you best of both the sweet and the swelter. A pineapple, the heat of jalapeños, and a splash of sriracha.

  • A pepperoni and sausage pizza on a wooden table, with bowls of shredded cheese, pizza sauce, pepperoni slices, and cooked sausage crumbles.

    TRI-WORKS

    $14.99

    A meat-lover’s slice with fresh Italian sausage, pepperoni, and bacon.

  • Cheese pizza on a wooden table with small bowls of cheese, shredded cheese, black pepper, paprika, and pickles nearby, and a container of tomato sauce.

    STICKS

    $9.99

    Our traditional pizza crust, brushed with garlic olive oil, seasoned with spices, and sprinkled mozzarella, asiago, cheddar, and parmesan. Served with a side of our house-made red sauce.

  • A freshly baked pizza with cheese, tomato sauce, and green herbs on a round wooden board surrounded by basil leaves, with small bowls of marinara sauce, shredded cheese, and sour cream nearby.

    MARGHERITA

    $9.99

    A traditional Italian pie with thin crust, garden-fresh basil, and our fresh mozzarella.

  • Uncooked pizza topped with cheese, sliced onions, and green olives, on a wooden pizza peel. Surrounding it are bowls of chopped onions, shredded cheese, tomato sauce, pine nuts, chopped artichokes, sliced jalapenos, and cooked ground beef.

    MARTHA'S DELUXE

    $14.99

    Rich and flavorful, this pizza features: fresh sausage, green olives, red onions, artichoke hearts, pine nuts, our mozzarella cheese blend, and complemented by a sprinkling of robust gorgonzola.

  • Freshly baked pizza topped with cheese, ham, and green herbs on a wooden table, surrounded by sliced onions, sliced prosciutto, and small bowls of green sauce, sun-dried tomatoes, shredded cheese, blue cheese, and olive oil.

    PETE'S DRAGON

    $14.99

    A garlic olive oil sauce, sun-dried tomatoes, red onion, prosciutto, our mozzarella cheese blend, a pesto drizzle, and a dash of gorgonzola to mix things up a bit!

  • Pizza on a wooden table with pepperoni, onions, and cheese, along with side ingredients including sliced pepperoni, shredded cheese, chopped onions, tomato sauce, and red pepper flakes.

    RED DEVIL

    $13.99

    A combination of pepperoni, sun-dried tomatoes, red onion, roasted red pepper, and a sprinkle of fresh Parmesan over our mozzarella cheese blend.

  • Unbaked pizza with toppings on a wooden pizza peel surrounded by ingredients including shredded cheese, cooked bacon, broccoli, potatoes, garlic, shredded cheese, and pizza sauce.

    RE-LOADED POTATO

    $13.99

    Classic baked potato toppings on a pizza?! Try this new version of a vintage Martha’s pizza with Alfredo sauce, garlic, house-blend cheese, broccoli, bacon, roasted potato, and cheddar.

  • Cheese pizza topped with sliced yellow and purple onions on a round wooden pizza peel, surrounded by small bowls of shredded cheese, pickled peppers, pineapple chunks, pine nuts, and dried black olives, with onion slices scattered around.

    THE PARENTE

    $14.99

    The Italian word for “family,” this pizza draws from traditional flavors and modern delivery: a house red sauce, artichoke hearts, house red sauce, roasted pine nuts, banana peppers, and parmesan.

  • Unbaked pizza with pepperoni, green peppers, onions, and black olives on a wooden peel, with ingredients including white mushrooms, shredded cheese, tomato sauce, green bell pepper, sliced onions, black olives, and sun-dried tomatoes arranged around it on a wooden surface.

    FAIRHAVEN

    $14.99

    A vegetarian spin with fresh mushrooms, onions, green peppers, Kalamata olives, and sun-dried tomatoes.

  • Unbaked pizza on a wooden pizza peel surrounded by tomatoes, basil, sliced onions, black olives, shredded cheese, and pizza sauce in small bowls.

    THE GREEK

    $13.99

    This Mediterranean-influenced pizza is salty and zesty, just like the Med itself. With fresh spinach, our house blend of cheeses, tomatoes, onions, Kalamata olives, then topped with feta and goat cheese, this one is sure to brighten up your day.

  • A cheese pizza topped with mushrooms and red onions, surrounded by small bowls of sliced garlic, onions, pine nuts, cooked mushrooms, shredded cheese, and grated cheese, all on a wooden table.

    THE WEBSTER

    $14.99

    Sautéed wild mushrooms, a garlic oil base, house blend cheeses, red onion, roasted garlic, cloves, and pine nuts.

CREATE YOUR OWN MASTERPIECE

Add to The Original starting at $9.99

  • HAND-TOSSED CRUSTS

    Nantucket Original • Gluten Free (+$3.00)

  • SAUCES AND SEASONINGS

    (Select Any)

    Martha's Signature Red • Creamy Alfredo • Garlic Olive Oil • Basil Pesto • Vegan Red Sauce • Cajun Seasoning • Italian Seasoning

  • MEATS

    (Add $1.50)

    Pepperoni • Prosciutto • Ham • Bacon • Chicken • Fresh Sausage

  • CHEESES

    (Add $1.00)

    Martha's Mozzarella Blend • Fresh Mozzarella • Parmesan • Asiago • Gorgonzola • Goat Cheese • Feta • Vegan Mozzarella (add $2.00)

  • VEGGIES

    (Add $1.00)

    Mushrooms • Red Onions • Green Peppers • Roasted Red Pepper • Banana Peppers • Green Olives • Kalamata Olives • Fresh Garlic • Fresh Spinach • Jalapeños • Diced Tomatoes • Sun-Dried Tomatoes • Broccoli • Fresh Basil • Artichoke Hearts • Pineapple • Raisins • Roasted Pine Nuts • Roasted Potatoes • Yellow Squash • Zucchini